Advertisement

'The Ring' too plain to be great

March 23, 2005

"The Ring Two" had everything going for it. It was a sequel to a

critical and commercial hit, and the star, Naomi Watts, had returned,

as did the writer and producers. The original director had been

replaced by Hideo Nakata, director of the Japanese "Ringu" trilogy on

which the two American versions are based. Still, "The Ring Two"

falls very short of greatness.

Picking up six months after the first film, we catch up with

Advertisement

Rachel Keller (Watts) and her son, Aidan (David Dorfman) as they

relocate to Astoria, Ore., leaving behind their horrific memories in

Seattle. Those memories involve the ghost of a little girl named

Samara (Burbank's own Kelly Stables), who was thrown into a deep well

and left to die by her depressed mother, who sealed the cylindrical

well off at the top -- leaving a "ring" of light around the circular

rim.

Samara's spirit found vengeance in the form of a videotape that

would curse the viewer to death in exactly one week. As Rachel found

out, the only way to lift the curse was to make a copy and help the

curse spread.

What's fresh about "The Ring Two" (PG-13) is that the videotape

device, while clever, is jettisoned early in favor of Samara's spirit

possessing Aidan -- all she wants is a mother, and if she takes over

his body, Rachel will fill that void. This creates a paradox; the

only way to save her son is to kill him.

What's missing from the sequel is the believability of Rachel's

actions and audience identification with the characters. Rachel does

things that don't make sense because it's convenient for the plot. If

you don't buy what's motivating her, you don't engage as deeply, and

therefore are far less likely to be scared.

* ALLEN MACDONALD works in the television industry and resides in

Toluca Lake.

'Hostage' has violence to the max

If you're a fan of Bruce Willis, you should see the new movie

"Hostage." If violence and blood make you squirm, avoid this film

from Miramax.

First let me say that I'm a big Bruce Willis fan. Willis'

performance in "Die Hard" is one of my favorites. Even if the paper

hadn't asked me to review "Hostage," I still would have seen it.

Since I'm a pro, I'll still give you an unbiased critique.

"Hostage" stars Willis as Jeff Talley, the sheriff of a small town

in Ventura County. He's moved there to escape his old life as a

hostage negotiator in Los Angeles. As usual, trouble follows the

sheriff wherever he goes, and he finds himself once again negotiating

a hostage situation.

This time, there's a twist. The bad guys are holding his family

Burbank Leader Articles
|
|
|