In Theory:

At the same time, we all share a vital obligation to make sure that members of our society do not go hungry or lack the basic necessities of life. This fundamental compassion to our fellow man is a cornerstone of our civilized way of life. Therefore, donating to a food-bank or shelter is a good idea for concerned citizens who want to ensure that their charity serves a positive end. Such a donation helps give basic sustenance to the needy while denying those who want to nourish their addictions. It is a safe way to show care for those less fortunate.

Ultimately, however, we must recognize that it will take far more than simple food handouts to solve the ever-growing problem of our homeless population. I would advise those seeking a lasting solution to this crisis to heed the wisdom of the Twelfth Century rabbi and philosopher, Moses Maimonides. He stated that the greatest level of charity is to assist a person in finding a job and to strengthen his hand until he no longer needs assistance. As the saying goes: “Give a person a fish and you feed them for a day. Teach them to fish, and you feed them for life.”

RABBI SIMCHA BACKMAN

Chabad Jewish Center

?

As a general rule, I agree. Many of those who live on the street are there as a result of addiction to drugs or alcohol. Giving money does not necessarily help the root cause of homelessness. In fact, it often perpetuates an unfortunate situation without offering hope for a positive change in life’s direction.

There are reputable organizations in most communities that assist those who lack basic necessities. Our local community, for example, provides outreach through organizations such as “Loaves and Fishes,” “Food for Body and Soul” and “Project Achieve.” Religious congregations are also equipped to help the poor with specific needs and reach out according to their own abilities. The support of relief agencies, local churches and other religious bodies provide real, hands-on assistance to those in need.

With all of that being said, is it ever appropriate to give a handout? Only the giver can discern a particular situation. If someone is hungry, perhaps a gift certificate to a local fast food restaurant might be more beneficial in the long run than handing out cash.