The left-hander started the game strongly, hurling a one-hitter through the first four innings as Chapman jumped out to a 8-0 lead. However, he got into trouble in the fifth, as he was pulled after surrendering four runs.
The Panthers were able to win the game, 15-4, forcing a winner-take-all game later Tuesday against Marietta at Fox Cities Stadium in Grand Chute, Wis.
Unfortunately for Chapman, it couldn't claim the title, falling, 18-5, to the Pioneers.
Chapman kept its national-title hopes alive with a dramatic victory on Monday in the NCAA tournament. Freshman outfielder Adam Velez delivered the game-winning base hit to center field that plated Troy Newman with the winning run to keep the Panthers alive with a 3-2 win over Buena Vista University (Iowa).
Along with a 9-4 loss to Marietta, Chapman also earned wins against Wisconson-Whirewater, 4-2, and Kean University, 9-4, in the tournament.
The Panthers were trying to win their first national championship since 2003, and third in school history.
The Panthers (37-13) earned a spot in the tournament with a winning performance in regional play.
Down by a run, Chapman rallied and scored two runs in the ninth inning, capped by the game-winning RBI single by sophomore Tyler Surnbrock, to pull out an 8-7 victory over Linfield College on May 21 at Walt Driggers Field in Abeline, Texas.
With the win, the Panthers captured their sixth regional championship in the last seven seasons, and seventh overall under head Coach Tom Tereschuk.
Going into Tuesday's games, Levitt, a junior relief pitcher, had a 2-1 record, two saves, 22 strikeouts and a 3.60 earned-run average in 13 appearances out of the bullpen.
Kerry Hodgins (University of New Mexico softball; Burroughs High): Hodgins, a former All-Area standout for the Indians, ended a successful season as a starting outfielder for the Lobos.
Hodgins also helped a resurgence in the program under first-year Coach Erica Beach.