Burroughs (14-6-3), which won the Pacific League title, will now play Redlands East Valley or Norte Vista in Wednesday’s second round.
While Gerlach and Izqueta led the offensive attack to four consecutive goals, goalie Elliot Whitecotton came up clutch in the second half, as the Colonists mounted a furious rally. He finished with nine saves, seven of them coming in the second half against 13 Anaheim shots.
“They got a second wind,” Burroughs Coach Mike Kodama said of Anaheim. “They had to throw everything forward and they did.
“Elliott came up big for us in the second half.”
Anaheim (14-8-1), the Orange League’s third-place squad which defeated Beckman in a wild-card match on Wednesday, jumped out to a 1-0 lead with a goal in the 11th minute, but the Indians rallied — and then some.
“We started off a little slow,” Izqueta said. “We started touching on them a little bit and they started chasing. That’s how we play.”
As the Indians’ passing game blossomed and their up-tempo run of play began to take shape, Anaheim began to wane, but it was set pieces that ultimately turned the table.
“We just had to relax,” Kodama said. “We did very well on the set pieces and that turned the whole game.”
Burroughs tied the match in the 19th minute when Izqueta took a left-footed free kick from just outside the goal box and perfectly placed it to Gerlach, who headed the ball on a bounce into the net.
“We knew we had to stay calm and work the ball,” Gerlach said, “and that’s what we did.”
Four minutes later, Nolberto Alcantar scored the go-ahead tally when he drilled home a low shot off an excellent long throw from Gerlach.