Burroughs had tied the score in the seventh to extend the game, but could not get a hit after that, leading to a thrilling finish as Arcadia executed an 11th-inning suicide squeeze to win, 4-3.
The loss drops Burroughs to 12-9, 6-2 in league, while Arcadia improves to 15-6-6-2. Both trail league-leading Burbank (12-7, 7-1), which defeated Hoover on Tuesday, 13-3.
Both teams had gone without a hit in the extra innings until Arcadia's Cameron Tuck led off the 11th with a sharply hit single to left field off of Burroughs reliever Daniel Barraza, who had taken over mound duties with two outs in the seventh. Tuck advanced to second on a wild pickoff attempt and then to third on a sacrifice bunt. Then, Apache Matt Morales successfully bunted the second pitch of his at-bat to the no-man's land between Barraza and the Indians' third baseman, allowing Tuck to score the game-winning run without a play.
"That is just good baseball. It's good execution," Holmes said of the game's final play. "It's one of those things that you know it's coming, but if you do it right you can't stop it. They did it right and we couldn't stop it."
The win went to lefty Jonathan Hopkins, who came on to pitch in the top of the eighth and held Burroughs scoreless and hitless through his four innings of work, striking out four, despite walking five.
Hopkins had walked the bases loaded with one out in the 10th inning, but escaped without harm. The senior struck out the next batter and then caught a screaming line drive off the bat of Jimmy Cramer to escape the jam and strand the three Indians standing on base. In total, Burroughs left 11 runners on base.
"This all comes down to runners left on base," Holmes said. "Some of it is bad luck. I mean, we had the bases loaded and two outs [in the 10th] and [if] that pitcher doesn't catch that line drive he's probably in the hospital ... We just couldn't get the hit when we needed to."